8 Comments

Thank you (I think you need a "like" button for when you want to show appreciation, but don't have anything meaningful to say)

Expand full comment

I agree - where else are we going to get this kind of reporting . Thanks guys

Expand full comment

I have actually found it. It is the little heart that appears only when you see only a snippet of the article when you start scrolling the comments. Well hidden indeed... I wonder why substack has it like that.

Expand full comment

Can Luke do a Pillar Draft Pick Syro-Malabar edition? That would be a wild podcast.

Expand full comment

I second this! It would be great either way but if JD is still under the weather, I vote this is the backup podcast plan.

Expand full comment

Long live Catholic India!

Expand full comment

"Therefore, the candidate chosen by the Eastern Church’s Synod of Bishops must also be approved by the pope."

Different writers seem to use different terms here, though maybe this is the difference between a Major Archbishop and a Patriarch. Does the Pope "approve" the election (i.e., "I like the guy. He's a real mensch." or "No, he drinks too much.") or does he offer ecclesial communion to him ("I accept you as an archbishop in communion with the See of Rome")?

Expand full comment

Good question. I'm not sure of the answer, but note that the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches says: "The new patriarch must as soon as possible request ecclesiastical communion from the Roman Pontiff by means of a letter signed in his own hand."

https://orthocath.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/1990_code_of_canons_of_the_eastern_churches.pdf

There's a description of the specific process in the Syro-Malabar Church here:

https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6ZEFFNbmT8sJ:https://www.cbci.in/Appointment-of-a-Bishop.aspx&hl=en&gl=uk

Expand full comment