Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter's avatar

This is interesting and I will want to keep an eye on how it works out in Poland, but at the moment I can't see it working in North America. A survey released October 2022 by CUA looking at trust and burnout in priests reported that less than half of priests trust their own diocesan bishop and less than a quarter trust the bishops as a group. Those are dismal numbers. I think in North America, this would be taken as "We the bishops have the right to mess with you priests as we please, and if you don't like it, well, talking about it publicly is also a crime so there." I think that there is a place for rules like these, ones that are more narrow and precise in focus, but similar. However, there needs to be a lot of trust rebuilt before anything like this is practically possible.

Expand full comment
Bisbee's avatar

I understand the idea, but this type of document could be used to stifle legitimate conversations, points of view and prudential judgements.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...